
Hotel Bardo Savannah
Best for travelers who want an upscale urban resort with a full-service spa, multiple bars/restaurants, and poolside social programming.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Hotel Bardo Savannah is a restored 1888 mansion turned five-star urban resort in Savannah’s Historic District with a full-service spa and a heated 25-meter outdoor pool. The Gardens by Tybee Vacation Rentals offers residential-style 3‑bedroom condo stays steps from Tybee Island Beach—good for groups and anyone wanting a beachside, home-like base.
Updated · about 18 miles / 29 km apart

Best for travelers who want an upscale urban resort with a full-service spa, multiple bars/restaurants, and poolside social programming.

Best for families or groups seeking a residential-style condo on Tybee Island within steps of the beach and a simple onsite pool.
When Hotel Bardo Savannah wins: pick Bardo if you want on-site dining options, a staffed spa (Saltgrass Spa), a large heated 25‑meter pool, and a central Historic District location for walking to museums, Forsyth Park, and SCAD.
When The Gardens by Tybee Vacation Rentals wins: choose The Gardens if your priority is direct beach access, a private-feel condo with a kitchen and balcony, or a quieter Tybee Island base for groups who plan to spend most of their time on the sand.
Bottom line: Hotel Bardo is an urban resort experience with full-service amenities and social spaces; The Gardens is a practical beachside condo for guests who want a home-like stay on Tybee Island.
| Category | Hotel Bardo Savannah | The Gardens by Tybee Vacation Rentals |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Polished urban resort, social spaces and programmed events | Residential beach condo, quiet gardenlike grounds |
| Location | Historic District beside Forsyth Park (walking distance to landmarks) | South Beach, Tybee Island—steps from Tybee Island Beach |
| Size | 149 rooms (50 suites) | Condo (3 Bedrooms) — single unit listing |
| Who can check in | Primary guest must be 21+ (children allowed with guardian) | Minimum check-in age 25 (per listing) |
| Pool(s) | Heated 25‑meter outdoor pool, open year-round for guests | One outdoor pool on property |
| Restaurants & bars | Multiple venues: Saint Bibiana (coastal Italian), The Green Room, Bar Bibi, Club Bardo | One on-site restaurant |
| Spa & fitness | Saltgrass Spa (treatments, sauna) and 24‑hour fitness center | Not published |
| Known for | Historic-mansion architecture, social club, events and weddings | Beach access and gardenlike residential atmosphere |
| Suitability | Good for couples, families, business and event groups | Good for families/groups wanting a condo and beach time |
| Parking & access | Valet parking (surcharge), EV charging, house car | Free self parking onsite; check-in location info differs |
Hotel Bardo sits on Drayton Street in Savannah’s Historic District, directly across from Forsyth Park.
Choose Bardo for a central Savannah stay within easy walking distance of Historic District sites.
The Gardens is located at 404 Butler Avenue on Tybee Island, a short walk to South Beach.
Choose The Gardens if direct beach proximity on Tybee Island is your priority.
Hotel Bardo offers 149 guest rooms including 50 suites and several room types named for local views and features.
Pick Bardo for a range of hotel rooms and suites with on-site service and event facilities.
The Gardens listing is a single 3‑bedroom condo with full kitchen and private balcony.
Choose The Gardens for a home-style 3‑bedroom unit with kitchen and balcony at the beach.
Hotel Bardo has multiple staffed dining and bar venues on property.
Bardo is better if you want varied on-site dining and evening lounges without leaving the hotel.
The Gardens provides one on-site restaurant and a self-catered kitchen in the condo.
The Gardens suits guests who value a kitchen and occasional on-site dining rather than multiple restaurants.
Hotel Bardo’s centerpiece pool is a heated 25‑meter outdoor pool available to guests and club members.
Bardo’s large heated pool and poolside bar are ideal when you want a hotel pool experience in the city.
The Gardens has one outdoor pool and immediate beach access a short walk from the unit.
The Gardens is better if your priority is the ocean and a condo with direct beach access.
Hotel Bardo combines Saltgrass Spa and a 24‑hour fitness center with evening entertainment and family activities.
Bardo fits travelers who want full-service spa and wellness plus curated evening programming.
The Gardens listing does not publish a staffed spa or large wellness program.
Choose The Gardens for low-key recreation, beach activities, and self-guided family time rather than on-site spa services.

Hotel Bardo — Saltgrass Spa, treatments, sauna, and a dedicated fitness center.

The Gardens — steps from Tybee Island Beach and within easy walking distance of South Beach.

Hotel Bardo — multiple restaurants and bars, plus Club Bardo for 21+ social evenings.

The Gardens — a 3‑bedroom condo with kitchen and balcony for family or group stays.
Hotel Bardo is in Savannah’s Historic District beside Forsyth Park, within walking distance of many downtown attractions; The Gardens is on Tybee Island about a 20–30 minute drive away.
Hotel Bardo offers Saltgrass Spa with a published menu and hours; The Gardens listing does not publish an on-site spa.
Both can work: Hotel Bardo welcomes children (check-in age 21 for the primary guest) and runs Camp Bardo activities, while The Gardens offers a full 3‑bedroom condo that’s convenient for family self-catering and beach time.
The Gardens condo includes a full kitchen; Hotel Bardo rooms do not list full kitchens (hotel dining and room service are available).
Explore how Hotel Bardo Savannah stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·