
Hotel Bardo Savannah
Best for travelers who want a serviced urban resort with restaurants, a spa, and a heated 25-meter pool steps from Forsyth Park.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Hotel Bardo Savannah is a restored 1888 mansion turned full-service, five-star urban resort in Savannah’s Historic District; read this if you want a polished city resort with on-site dining, a spa, and a heated 25-meter pool. Cake by the Ocean Tybee Vacation Rentals is a privately managed, playful Tybee Island vacation home with a private pool a short walk from South Beach; read this if you want easy beach access and a rental-style stay for a small group or family.
Updated · about 18 miles apart

Best for travelers who want a serviced urban resort with restaurants, a spa, and a heated 25-meter pool steps from Forsyth Park.

Best for groups or families seeking a private Tybee Island house near South Beach with a private outdoor pool and kitchen.
When Hotel Bardo Savannah wins: choose Bardo if you want in‑house restaurants and bars, scheduled programming, a full-service spa and fitness center, valet parking/house car service, and a heated 25‑meter pool in the center of Savannah’s Historic District.
When Cake by the Ocean wins: pick Cake by the Ocean for a beach-focused escape—a privately decorated house with a private pool, easy walking access to Tybee’s South Beach and pier, and a rental-style layout with a kitchen and private patio.
Bottom line: Hotel Bardo is a full-service, amenity-rich urban resort ideal for guests who want on-site dining and spa services; Cake by the Ocean is a simpler, playful Tybee vacation home best for short stays near the sand when you don’t need full resort services.
| Category | Hotel Bardo Savannah | Cake by the Ocean Tybee Vacation Rentals |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Full-service, polished urban resort centered on a restored mansion | Casual, privately decorated beach house rental |
| Location | 700 Drayton St, beside Forsyth Park in Savannah’s Historic District | 1706 Inlet Avenue, Tybee Island (South Beach), a short walk to the beach |
| Size / rooms | 149 rooms, including multiple suites across a four‑building property | House (Cake by the Ocean) — single vacation home rather than a hotel |
| Who can check in | Primary guest must be 21+ to check in; children allowed with guardian | Check-in minimum age 25 (property policy); not adults-only |
| Pools | Heated 25‑meter outdoor pool (year-round) reserved for guests and Club Bardo members | Private outdoor pool for the house; outdoor sun loungers and fenced yard |
| Restaurants & bars | Multiple on-site venues including Saint Bibiana (coastal Italian), The Green Room, Bar Bibi, and Club Bardo | Not published |
| Spa & fitness | Saltgrass Spa (massages, facials, infrared sauna) and 24‑hour Technogym/Peloton fitness center | Not published |
| Known for | Historic mansion setting, in-house dining and spa services, Club Bardo and event/wedding spaces | Short walk to Tybee beaches, private pool, and a kitchen-equipped vacation home |
| Parking & access | Valet parking (surcharge), EV charging, house car and nearby street parking | Limited on-site parking; self check-in with access code (no front desk) |
| Wi‑Fi | Complimentary high‑speed Wi‑Fi throughout ('Bardo Guest') | |
Hotel Bardo sits at 700 Drayton Street directly across from Forsyth Park in Savannah’s Historic District.
Best base for sightseeing and dining in historic downtown Savannah.
Cake by the Ocean is located at 1706 Inlet Avenue on Tybee Island’s South Beach neighborhood.
Choose this if you want to spend most of your time on the beach and near the pier.
Hotel Bardo offers 149 guest rooms and 50 suites with several named suite types.
Multiple room types and on-site services suit travelers who want choices and hotel support.
Cake by the Ocean is a single vacation home rental with multiple beds and pool access.
A private house layout with a kitchen and outdoor space for groups or families.
Hotel Bardo features multiple on-site restaurants and bars that cover most meal needs.
If you prefer on-site dining and cocktail options, Bardo keeps you covered without leaving the property.
Cake by the Ocean provides a kitchen for self-catering; no published on-site restaurants.
Good for travelers who want to cook or eat locally rather than rely on hotel restaurants.
Hotel Bardo offers a heated 25‑meter outdoor pool open year-round to guests and Club members.
A sizable, heated lap-style pool with staffed poolside service for resort guests.
Cake by the Ocean has a private outdoor pool and fenced outdoor entertainment area.
A private pool plus immediate beach access makes this rental well-suited for beach-focused stays.
Hotel Bardo has a full-service Saltgrass Spa and a 24-hour fitness center with scheduled classes.
Comprehensive spa, fitness and evening programming for guests who want on-site wellness and nightlife.
Cake by the Ocean does not publish an on-site spa or fitness center.
Expect a low-key wellness/nightlife scene centered on outdoor activities and the local island community.

Hotel Bardo — multiple restaurants and bars including Saint Bibiana, The Green Room and Bar Bibi.

Cake by the Ocean — a private house a short walk from South Beach with its own fenced pool.

Hotel Bardo — Saltgrass Spa and a 24-hour fitness center with Technogym and Peloton equipment.

Cake by the Ocean — kitchen, furnished patio, and a private pool for groups who prefer a rental.
Cake by the Ocean is on Tybee Island and about a 5‑minute walk to South Beach; Hotel Bardo is in downtown Savannah about 18 miles from Tybee.
Yes — Hotel Bardo allows children when accompanied by a parent/guardian (primary check-in 21+). Cake by the Ocean is a family-friendly rental; the property’s check-in minimum is listed as 25 but it is not adults-only.
Yes — Hotel Bardo has a heated 25‑meter outdoor pool for guests and members; Cake by the Ocean has a private outdoor pool for the rental.
Hotel Bardo — it has the Saltgrass Spa, a 24‑hour fitness center, and organized fitness programming. Cake by the Ocean has no published spa or fitness facilities.
Explore how Hotel Bardo Savannah stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·